Blog Details

Sep 25, 2026

Divided We Stand: The Role of Conflict in the Creation of the American Constitution

Welcome back to the blog of Dale Dungan Pullen (late), where we dig into themes from his book, The 17th of September 1787: Constitution Day. In the last blog, we covered why another book on the Constitution was even necessary. Today, we take you inside the convention.

Most Americans picture the Constitutional Convention as a dignified gathering of Founding Fathers. Pullen’s book tells a messier story. Fifty-five delegates spent four months, May through September 1787, locked in a sweltering Philadelphia statehouse with the windows shut to keep the proceedings secret. No air conditioning, no fans, and, as Pullen notes, not much in the way of deodorant either!

And that was just the beginning of the disputes.

A Country Coming Apart

Before anything could be debated, the delegates had to agree that something drastic was even needed. The country they were trying to fix was in bad shape. The states were acting like rival nations rather than partners, a financial depression had settled in, farmers were losing land to debt collectors, and Massachusetts had just put down an armed uprising known as Shays’ Rebellion. The Articles of Confederation, the loose agreement holding the states together since the Revolutionary War, gave the national government no power to do anything about these issues.

So the delegates arrived in Philadelphia agreeing on one thing: the current system had to go. James Madison, a 36-year-old Virginia planter who had spent months studying the history of failed republics before the convention even started, showed up with a blueprint. It became known as the “Virginia Plan,” and it proposed a strong national government split into three branches, a structure the delegates adopted early and never seriously challenged.

But everything else was not so smooth.

The Dispute That Almost Killed the Convention

Here’s the thing. Once the delegates agreed on three branches of government, they still had to decide how many votes each state got in the legislature, and that question nearly ended the whole enterprise.

Madison’s Virginia Plan called for representation based on population, which favored large states like Virginia, Pennsylvania, and Massachusetts. Small states like New Jersey and Delaware saw this as a death sentence for their political influence. On June 15, New Jersey’s William Paterson countered with his own proposal, keeping the one-state-one-vote system already in place under the Articles. The convention split into two camps, and for weeks neither side would budge.

James Wilson of Pennsylvania warned that if the small states wouldn’t accept proportional representation, his state would “confederate on no other” plan. Connecticut’s Roger Sherman, described in Pullen’s book as a man of few but direct words, floated a compromise as early as June 11: population-based representation in one legislative chamber, equal representation in the other. It went nowhere that day. Delegates kept circling back to fixed positions, and even Benjamin Franklin’s appeal to reason and moderation couldn’t move them.

By July, the convention was at what Sherman called a “full stop.” An eleven-member committee, one delegate per state, was formed to find a way out. On July 16, by a razor-thin 5-4 vote, the delegates approved what became known as the Great Compromise (also called the Connecticut Compromise): representation by population in the House, equal representation in the Senate. Edmund Randolph, on the losing side of that vote, called it a “frightening embarrassment” and floated the idea of adjourning so the large states could regroup. It didn’t happen. The vote held, and the fracture that had threatened to end the convention closed.

The Slavery Debate That Shaped the Constitution

Representation, though, wasn’t a clean fight. It ran straight into the second devil Pullen identifies in the convention: chattel slavery. The question of how, or whether, to count enslaved people toward a state’s representation set off some of the angriest exchanges of the summer, and it never really resolved.

Neither the word “slave” nor “slavery” appears anywhere in the Constitution. Delegates found euphemisms for it instead. Enslaved people became “three-fifths of all other persons” for purposes of representation. An escaped slave was a “person held to service or labor” under what became the fugitive slave clause, requiring return to their owner even from a state where slavery was illegal. The delegates knew exactly what they were writing around, and Pullen documents delegates on both sides saying so out loud.

Some delegates spoke with real moral discomfort. Gouverneur Morris of Pennsylvania called slavery “the curse of heaven” and pointed out the contradiction of treating enslaved people as property in some clauses and as people in others. Virginia’s George Mason, himself an owner of more than 200 enslaved people, warned that slaveholders were “petty tyrants” who would bring divine judgment on the country. But when South Carolina’s John Rutledge made clear that his state and Georgia would walk out of the convention entirely if slavery were restricted, telling delegates that “religion and humanity had nothing to do with this question,” the moral objections gave way to political necessity. Connecticut’s Roger Sherman put it plainly: better to let the trade continue than lose the Southern states from the union altogether.

The result was the same three-fifths formula tied into the representation compromise, plus a clause protecting the slave trade from federal restriction until 1808. Pullen’s research shows that in the twenty-one years the clause bought, more than 200,000 additional enslaved people were brought into the country. It would take a civil war and a constitutional amendment nearly eighty years later to undo what the convention refused to touch.

Who Runs the Country, and How Do You Choose Them?

By late summer, one major question remained unsettled: how to select the nation’s chief executive. It sounds procedural, but it wasn’t. Delegates spent the better part of the summer, and much of September, arguing over it.

The original Virginia Plan had the national legislature choose the president. However, Gouverneur Morris and Madison argued that this would make the executive dependent on Congress, undermining the separation of powers the delegates had already agreed to. Madison pointed to state governments where legislatures dominated weak governors, calling the latter “mere ciphers.”

But letting ordinary citizens choose the president directly made plenty of delegates nervous. Elbridge Gerry of Massachusetts thought direct popular election would be “vicious,” rooted in what he called the “ignorance of the people.” Others, including John Dickinson of Delaware, argued the opposite, that the people choosing their own executive was the “best and purest method” available.

The fight dragged into September before the Committee on Postponed Parts produced the compromise that stuck: a state’s number of electors would equal its combined total of senators and representatives, with state legislatures deciding how those electors were chosen. It was neither full popular election nor legislative appointment. It was, like nearly everything else that summer, a split-the-difference arrangement built to get enough delegates to say yes.

What the Fighting Actually Produced

Put these three fights side by side, and a pattern shows up. The Constitution wasn’t the product of shared vision executed smoothly. It was the product of delegates who fundamentally disagreed on questions of power, humanity, and government structure, finding just enough common ground to keep fifty-five very stubborn men in the same room until September.

Pullen’s account of the Federal Convention pulls together delegate quotes, committee votes, and the day-by-day sequence behind each compromise in far more detail than fits in a single post, tracing how each fight fed into and complicated the others. If the mechanics of how a divided room produced a functioning government interest you, that’s where the fuller record lives.

That’s it for today. Stay tuned for more from the convention floor. And if you haven’t already, get a copy of The 17th of September 1787: Constitution Day.